Trick-Or-Treat Halloween Surprise Cookies

So I’m feeling generous. It’s one more day until Halloween and we need to find a way to share all the Halloween spookiness and fun that we can squeeze in. This totally calls for a celebratory cookie…and not just any ol’ cookie–a cookie that screams Halloween.  As I shared with my last post, I’m on a pressing deadline for the rest of the year. Unfortunately this means for the time being I don’t have time I would like to make another recipe for this special occasion so I decided, What the Hades! I will share with you one of my favorite recipes from my Halloween e-book (which is still up for sale by the way) It’s never too late to celebrate Fork & Beans style…


I call these Trick-or-Treat Pumpkin Cookies. Why you might ask?

Halloween Surprise Cookies - Fork & Beans

They look like a typical cookie in the shape of a pumpkin. There is nothing special or tricky about them! Au contraire mon frère (Yeah, I totally had to Google that to figure out how to spell it). To that I say, OH YEAH? Well, take this:

Halloween Surprise Cookies - Fork & Beans

SURPRISE!! Trick-or-Treat! Didn’t see that one coming now did you? Who knew that goodies were awaiting you inside once you cracked them open with your teeth (I knew…but then again that was a rhetorical question).

Trick-or-Treat Surprise Cookies
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
  • ⅓ c. vegan butter
  • ⅓ c. shortening
  • 1 c. granulated sugar
  • 1 tsp. Ener-G Egg replacer + 2 Tb water
  • 2 tsp. baking soda
  • 1 Tbsp. nondairy milk
  • ½ tsp. vanilla
  • natural food coloring (red and yellow for orange)
  • 2 c. Cara's All-Purpose flour blend
  • 1 tsp. xanthan gum
  • pinch sea salt
Royal Icing (combine until thick):
  • ½ c. powdered sugar
  • ½ tsp. water
  • Red and yellow all natural food coloring
Additional needs:
  • Pumpkin cookie cutter
  • Circle cookie cutter (must be small enough to fit inside middle of pumpkin cutter)
  • Sprinkles/candy of choice for the inside of the cookies
  1. Preheat oven to 375 degrees.
  2. Thoroughly cream the shortening, butter, sugar, and vanilla together. Add egg replacer and milk until light and fluffy. Add the orange food coloring and mix. Whisk flour, xanthan gum, baking soda, and salt together in a separate bowl. Add flour into the creamed mixture until combined. Divide the dough in half, cover in plastic wrap and chill for 1 hour.
  3. Between 2 pieces of parchment paper, roll the dough out to ¼" thickness. Cut into pumpkins with cutters. For each pumpkin set, you will need 4 cookies; 2 of which will need circles cut out of them prior to placing them into the oven. Place on parchment paper-lined baking sheet.
  4. Bake for 6-8 minutes. Allow to cool.
  5. To assemble cookies:
  6. Place the bottom pumpkin cookie (without a circle cut-out) first.
  7. Outline the cookie with the royal icing. Place a cookie with a circle cut out on top. Press firmly to set. Repeat with another circle cut out pumpkin cookie.
  8. Place sprinkles, candy or whatever you please inside the hollow center. Outline with royal icing and close with remaining pumpkin cookie (without a circle cut-out). Allow to set for 15 minutes.


You can use my flour blend found here to make these cookies or simply use your own favorite blend. Here is a guide to show you the progression of building your own Trick-or-Treat cookie:

Halloween Surprise Cookies - Fork & Beans

So this is my grand finale to wishing you and your loved ones a very HAPPY HALLOWEEN! May the candy gods be in your favor this year and may you fill your bellies with the finest gluten, egg, and dairy-free Halloween treats that you can withhold.


Halloween Surprise Cookies - Fork & Beans






OptinMonster allows you to explode your email list by using our incredible exit intent technology.


  1. This is so great! How much real egg would I use instead of the egg replacer? Or can I use a flax egg maybe?

  2. Well this is just so creative- I could almost venture to say genius? If you got the right sprinkles, people could even be momentarily fooled that bugs were falling out of their cookies- perfect!

  3. You’re a genius! There’s a ton of filling possibilities here 😀

  4. Linda Arnold says:

    Love it! Very creative!

  5. I actually giggled snorted! You are the BEST, Cara! SO. Freakin’. Talented! Happy Halloween, girl. xx

  6. Yay I love pinata cookies, love that you’ve done a spooky halloween version :) I’ve planned to do christmas ones for my little brothers and sister filled with peppermint candy! :) x

  7. I am speecless & in total awe!

  8. these are beyond awesome! how do u get these ideas! its like a treasure in there :)

  9. Haha that is so hilariously awesome! I love it!

  10. This is one of the coolest ideas I have ever seen! At first I was thinking “wait how do you bake them without the candies melting?” but then my brain kicked into gear.

    P.S. – I am constantly Googling spellings and expressions for blog posts.

  11. You clever girl you! You should freeze the leftover cookies and fill them with cooked pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving, too. Oh, what a smart cookie.

  12. lady, you are so freakin creative, it’s insane. LOVE.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: